Forum

You must be logged in to post Login

Search Forums:


 






Actual tongue weight of 14RB?

No Status Selected
No Tags
UserPost

12:50 am
March 13, 2011


pfidahospud

Post Falls, Idaho

Member

posts 107

Post edited 7:55 am – March 13, 2011 by pfidahospud


So, for kicks today I got out the bathroom scale to weigh the actual tongue weight on my 14RB.  The stated weight printed on the inside of the wardrobe door is 240 pounds.  With a full propane tank, 2 group 24 12-volt batteries, regular stuff inside but nothing especially heavy, and all clear/gray/black tanks empty, the scale showed something more than 300 pounds!  I'd like to know and give a real number, but that's all the scale goes up to.  Has anyone else weighed their trailer and compared it to what was stated?
Thanks!

Stephen

Tow-er: 2010 RAV4 3.5L 269 hp V6 with Tow Pkg ~ Tow-ee: 2011 Sportsmen Classic 14RB ~ Director: The wife

11:28 am
March 13, 2011


Suzy-Q

Oklahoma

Member

posts 54

Stephen;

You can get a total weight by setting up a platform with the scale under one end.  If you set the tongue jack in the middle of the platform, the weight at each end will be 1/2.  Therefore you just double the scale reading.

The 240lbs is most likely the dry weight without the propane tank and batteries.  Our dry tongue weight says 180lbs but is 230 on the scale with no tank one battery.

John

2010 14RK , 300W solar

7:03 pm
March 13, 2011


pfidahospud

Post Falls, Idaho

Member

posts 107

Thanks for the tip, John.  I'll try to find a scrap 2×4 or something to try that out and report back.  And yes, I do understand that the stated weight is dry weight, but I wasn't expecting it to be that different.  I may even take the batteries and propane tank off temporarily and weigh it again to see how that changes things.

Stephen

Tow-er: 2010 RAV4 3.5L 269 hp V6 with Tow Pkg ~ Tow-ee: 2011 Sportsmen Classic 14RB ~ Director: The wife

11:33 am
March 14, 2011


DougB

Charlotte, NC

Member

posts 31

I have a 16BH with an advertised dry tongue weight of 290 lbs.  I was astonished to find it to be over 400 lbs with battery, propane, and a few items in the trailer.  My suspicion is the dry weight does not include other optional items I have such as the A/C and front window. It took considerable effort to move the contents around to get below the 350 lb limit of my TV.

From reading various forums this method appears to be the standard for weighing with bathroom scales:

http://auto.howstuffworks.com/…..eight1.htm

I would be interested to know what others are finding for actual tongue weights and for that matter actual trailer weights.  One day I hope to get to a scale to find mine.

Doug

2010 16BH; RAV4 V6

7:35 pm
March 14, 2011


pfidahospud

Post Falls, Idaho

Member

posts 107

Update:

So today, I got the scale out again today and set up an apparatus to (hopefully) accurately weigh the tongue.  It ended up looking like this:

The jack is centered 3' from each point: one side is stationary, the other is the scale.  So every scale reading would need to be doubled in order to be accurate.

The results (all tanks are dry, and the trailer has the usual light camping stuff):

Total tongue weight (including 2 grp 24 batteries and full propane tank): 380# Surprised

Weight with nothing on the tone (batteries and propane tank completely removed): 300#

Weight with only the batteries and no propane tank: 356#

I honestly was a little shocked.  I knew that I'd be close to my vehicle's intended max hitch weight of 350#, but didn't think it'd be that high.  And that's without water in the tank.  I doubt that anything in the gray/black tanks would affect the tongue weight too much since they're farther back.  I plan to go ahead with the plan to install a weight-distributing hitch (Valley #70270).  Another potential option is the Reese 350, but I'm concerned there isn't enough room in the middle of the tongue frame for my setup with the two batteries and propane tank.

Happy camping!

Stephen


Tow-er: 2010 RAV4 3.5L 269 hp V6 with Tow Pkg ~ Tow-ee: 2011 Sportsmen Classic 14RB ~ Director: The wife

8:28 pm
March 14, 2011


Mike Magee

near Tulsa OK

Member

posts 204

Hmmm, can't say that I'm surprised, actually.  I told the salesman that I guessed the tongue weight could run 400 lbs. with water and everything.  Sure enough, and it looks like I may have guessed too low!

The fresh water tank and hot water heater are just about midway between the hitch ball and the trailer's axle on the 14RB.  If both are full, that is 16 gallons or 132 lbs. of water.  So imagine another 65-70 lbs. on the hitch!  Frown  Adding some water to the black tank will help slightly, but it it a relatively short distance behind the axle so it won't matter as much as that fresh water will. 

Traveling with little or no water becomes almost mandatory for many folks under these circumstances.

2008 Toyota Highlander – 2011 Escape E14RB

8:28 am
March 15, 2011


sandersmr

Texas

Member

posts 338

Also something to consider, especially with the idea of carrying water.  For the 16BH, the CCC is only about 450 pounds.  It doesn't take long to exceed that when carrying water.

2010 16BH towed by 2002 F-150 Super Crew 4.6L V8

8:35 am
March 15, 2011


Suzy-Q

Oklahoma

Member

posts 54

Stephen;


AFAIK a WD hitch will not have much affect on your tongue weight.  A WD hitch transfers some of the weight from the rear axel to the front axel of your TV.  The purpose is to control sag at the hitch or reduce the weight on the rear axel. Are you within the weight limit of your rear axel? 

One way to get the tongue weight issue solved would be to take your TV to a welding and fabricating shop.  They should know if your TV and hitch can be beefed up for more weight.

I have done just that with our Safari van because even though I have a 350lb hitch and 230lb hitch weight, the Safari had a 200lb tongue weight rating.  It cost $160. I now feel comfortable that I am near 75% of all of the TV weight ratings. 

HTH;

John

2010 14RK , 300W solar

9:25 am
March 18, 2011


pfidahospud

Post Falls, Idaho

Member

posts 107

John -

Thanks for the reminder.  Here's what I know, and feel free to correct me: The actual aftermarket tow hitch is rated for 500# hitch weight, and 5000# towing capacity, so that's obviously not a problem.  The vehicle itself is rated at 350# hitch weight, and 3500# towing capacity.  When we tow, there's virtually no weight inside the car in the back (passengers, personal weight-lifting kitWink, etc).

So, for my situation, with a tongue weight between 350-400#, and a little noticeable sag from the towing vehicle (never any bottoming out situations yet), my intent is to spread out the load to the front of the car.  Handling hasn't been an issue at all, but I don't want it to ever be either.  I also intend to move as much trailer weight as possible aft, but really – there's not much in that category I can move.  The main issue, which is "the way it is", is the propane tank and the two batteries on the tongue. 

Last night I did a rough install of the hitch (picture here).  One glitch (hitch glitch?) that I was hoping to avoid is that there isn't much room on the tongue frame for the brackets that hold the trunion bars.  Most likely I'll have the welding shop install a bracket on each side to accomodate, but that shouldn't be a big deal at all.

Stephen

Tow-er: 2010 RAV4 3.5L 269 hp V6 with Tow Pkg ~ Tow-ee: 2011 Sportsmen Classic 14RB ~ Director: The wife

8:16 am
March 23, 2011


pfidahospud

Post Falls, Idaho

Member

posts 107

Update:

I took the trailer to the welding shop yesterday to deal with the hanger bracket issue for the weight-distributing hitch.  The solution ended up being very simple.  He cut off a corner of the bracket go around the existing battery frame, and it works great!  The ride was a lot better on the way home, and the RAV didn't look nearly as squatty in the rear end.  The cost ended up being around $90, which I thought was reasonable.  I haven't had any sway/wandering issues, so I don't think sway control is necessary to add, but I haven't completely ruled it out yet.  It wouldn't be hard to add later.

 

Other pics available here.

Happy camping!

Stephen

Tow-er: 2010 RAV4 3.5L 269 hp V6 with Tow Pkg ~ Tow-ee: 2011 Sportsmen Classic 14RB ~ Director: The wife

3:48 pm
March 24, 2011


pkrmspec

Jasper

Member

posts 5

I just took delivery of a 16bh and tow with a honda ridgeline.  The title says 2280 lbs but the first short trip home –11 mpg!!! wow! I came from towing a scamp 16 ft with side dinette around 2500-2700lbs and was used to getting 15-17 mpg.  Quite a difference – so will be curious to weigh the 16bh.  Hard to believe just the square shape vs the round scamp would make that much difference and the 16bh is listed as less weight.

Anybody have real weight on 16bh?  Or suggestions?


Maybe I need a real trip to test mpg before getting excited as the trip home was only 40 miles vs the scamp data based on 3000 mile trips.


Anyway, i may need gas vouchers from sportsman….

6:20 pm
March 24, 2011


sandersmr

Texas

Member

posts 338

Oh yeah, the shape of the 16BH will cause a lot more drag – it's not so much the weight as it is the surface area resisting the air.  I have a 16BH and have gotten anywhere from 9 – 11.5 towing with a F150.

2010 16BH towed by 2002 F-150 Super Crew 4.6L V8

2:00 pm
March 25, 2011


Steve

San Antonio, TX

Moderator

posts 193

Post edited 9:07 pm – March 25, 2011 by Steve


So, has anyone built a cone type thing to mount to the front of the 16bh yet?


No sooner after I posted this I went looking and found this site … http://www.nosecone.com/aepull.htm. No prices listed that I can find so far, but I'm hoping they're cheaper for travel trailers.

http://haven106.blogspot.com

3:36 pm
March 25, 2011


Mike Magee

near Tulsa OK

Member

posts 204

Post edited 6:20 pm – March 26, 2011 by Mike Magee


pkrmspec said:

I just took delivery of a 16bh and tow with a honda ridgeline.  The title says 2280 lbs but the first short trip home –11 mpg!!! wow! I came from towing a scamp 16 ft with side dinette around 2500-2700lbs and was used to getting 15-17 mpg.  Quite a difference – so will be curious to weigh the 16bh.  Hard to believe just the square shape vs the round scamp would make that much difference and the 16bh is listed as less weight.

Anybody have real weight on 16bh?  Or suggestions?


Maybe I need a real trip to test mpg before getting excited as the trip home was only 40 miles vs the scamp data based on 3000 mile trips.


Anyway, i may need gas vouchers from sportsman….


Oh, I suspect it's the shape, all right.  I was getting about 14.3 with my 17' Burro 'wide body' at 65 mph.  On my first 400 mile camping trip with the E14RB I kept the speed around 60 mph and averaged a bit over 12.  If I had gone 65 I think it would have been 11 or less, because the boxy shape does catch more wind.  Heading toward the CG I was bucking a strong headwind and that fill-up was only 10.66 mpg. 

I console myself in knowing that it would have taken years of new egg ownership to pay the cost difference with gas savings.   I'm money ahead with the KZ.

2008 Toyota Highlander – 2011 Escape E14RB

No Tags